Teaching In A Red State
Pay, Politics & the Reality of Teaching in Florida
$32K – $100K+
In this episode, veteran Florida educator Danielle Goodman pulls back the curtain on what public school teaching in Miami-Dade County really looks like — the pay, the politics, the book bans, the lockdown drills, and why she's still in the classroom after 15 years. From a $32,000 starting salary to six figures with supplements, she breaks down every rung of the ladder.
What you'll learn in this episode:
Why a second-career teacher started at $32,000 — and tripled over 15 years
How switching from elementary to high school unlocks extra income through supplements
What SAT and college essay tutoring pays on the side
How Florida's curriculum restrictions affect what teachers can and can't say in class
What the Don't Say Gay bill means for teachers day-to-day
Why Florida's teacher union has been significantly weakened — and what that means
The reality of lockdown drills, class sizes of 40–50, and spending your own money on supplies
What the top of the Florida teacher pay scale actually looks like after 25–30 years
How much can you earn as a teacher in Florida?
Florida ranks among the lowest-paying states for teachers. Pay increases significantly with school level, years of experience, and whether you take on supplemental roles. High school teachers have far more options to add to their base salary than elementary teachers.
Starting salary (elementary, Miami-Dade)~$32,000/yr
Mid-career high school teacher~$65,000–$80,000/yr
Extra period (no planning period)+$6,000–$7,000/yr
Club sponsorships / coaching supplements - varies
SAT / college essay tutoring (private)$75–$100/hr
Top of scale (25–30 years, with supplements)~$95,000–$100,000/yr
Moving into administration - above $100,000 possible
Benefits include a Florida state pension and Social Security — unlike some states where teachers must choose one or the other. Health insurance coverage ends at retirement, however.
Why do teachers stay?
For Danielle, teaching isn't simply about academics. Seeing struggling students succeed, helping teenagers prepare for college, and watching former students return years later as successful adults gives meaning to her work. She believes even helping a small percentage of students can make a lifelong difference—and that's what keeps many educators in the classroom despite difficult working conditions.
You may also like:
Teaching in Academia - A professor’s career →
Looking to Pivot? - Master LinkedIn →
FAQ
How much do Florida teachers make starting out?
Starting salaries in Miami-Dade County have historically been around $32,000–$40,000 per year, depending on the year and school district. Florida ranks third-lowest among U.S. states for teacher pay, according to Danielle, while the cost of living — especially in Miami — has risen sharply.
Can Florida teachers earn more than their base salary?
Yes — but mainly at the high school level. High school teachers can give up their planning period for an additional $6,000–$7,000 per year, take on paid club sponsorships or coaching, and tutor privately. SAT and college essay tutors in Florida typically charge $75–$100 per hour.
What is the maximum a Florida teacher can earn?
A high school teacher with 25–30 years of experience who takes on all available supplements can earn approximately $95,000–$100,000 per year. Moving into an administrative role such as student activities director or curriculum coordinator can push earnings above that.
Do Florida teachers get a pension?
Yes. Florida teachers receive both a state pension and Social Security upon retirement — an arrangement that differs from states like Illinois or California, where teachers may have to choose one or the other. Florida teachers do not retain health insurance after retirement, however.
What is the Don't Say Gay bill and how does it affect teachers?
The Parental Rights in Education Act, passed in Florida in 2022 and commonly called the "Don't Say Gay" bill, prohibits classroom discussion of sexual orientation and gender identity in certain grade levels. In practice, it also means teachers cannot use a student's preferred pronoun that differs from what appears in school records, and face potential parental complaints and job consequences if they do.
What's the teacher shortage situation in Florida?
Florida's teacher shortage has led the state to significantly lower certification requirements in recent years. Positions that once required a four-year degree plus rigorous testing can now be filled via fast-track pathways — a change Danielle describes as a major quality concern. High turnover is driven primarily by low pay relative to the cost of living, especially in South Florida.
Is teaching in Florida worth it financially?
The financial case is challenging, especially early in your career. The emotional rewards — connecting with students, making a lasting impact — are real, but the pay is low, the classroom conditions are difficult, and the political environment has added significant stress. Teachers who stay tend to find ways to supplement their income and, over 15–30 years, can build a stable career with a good pension.
This episode first aired on May 2025.